Home  |  NRA Documents  |  Road Costs  |  News  |  Guestbook  |  Links  

 

28th September 2002

Five million mile man says No to motorways
By Joe Rea

Pierce Kavanagh has a lifetime of driving experience, both in Ireland and in mainland Europe. With cost savings equivalent to half a dozen Bertie Bowls possible, Joe Rea asked him for his suggestions to solve Ireland's traffic problems.

Nonsense expenditure is a non-runner. This is critical now with the smell of budget deficits, more borrowing or increased taxation in the air.

Motorways surplus to traffic volume requirements are senseless. Traffic volume figures do not justify motorways in open country. This fact I have demonstrated in previous Journal articles. For example: on the road I know best from Cashel to Mitchelstown in round figures current traffic volume is 10,000 vehicles per day. The expected required capacity in 2019 is 15,000. Yet the plan is to provided a motorway with 55,000 capacity. Vanity and fantasy at its best.

How do such figures match reality? Recently I had a unique experience when I spoke to a man who in his lifetime had driven five million miles. Pierce Kavanagh, part of the Kavanagh bus dynasty at Urlingford in Co. Kilkenny is this five million mile man.

In almost 50 years of driving he has travelled 5 million miles. That's the equivalent of going to New York 1600 times or driving from Cork to Dublin almost 30,000 times. Such a man must know a thing or two about travel and roads.

Pierce is precise on road needs when he states "a motorway from Dublin to Portlaoise yes. By passes for major towns. After that motorways are not required - of course roads require major improvements - but not on motorway scale. It's a waste of money for Irish traffic volumes. Our traffic volume is not anything like the UK, Germany or France which are serviced by motorways.''

Then I asked, "what's the solution?''

"Upgrade existing major roads. This can be achieved by having a series of slow lanes at intervals all along the road. This enables traffic to move along, overtake and pass out quickly. I had seen it work to great effect internationally. Yes we need smooth, soft road surfaces as in Western Europe. Such roads are great to drive on, easy on man and bus. All of this would only cost a fraction of motorways.''


Pierce made reference on many occasions to his international road experience - what experience had he of such roads? He looked at me with surprise, his pioneer pin flashed at my lack of knowledge of his successful business (I only knew he sold the cheapest diesel between Cahir and Dublin).

Pierce explained, "I have just returned after driving a 10 day tour of Switzerland. Next week I will drive a bus to Lourdes. I enjoyed this work all my life. My passengers get a very special opportunity to see new countries at close range just sitting in a luxury coach. This especially applies to those who do not like flying and it's good value for money.''

Had Pierce driven in many European countries? "Nearly the whole lot of them over the years. Going from Finland in the North to Italy in the South. Travelling West to East, France to Czechoslovakia.

While we are waiting for by-passes and improved roads what simple suggestions would Pierce propose?

"No parking on the main streets of towns to allow traffic to flow freely - but with parking space available off the main thoroughfare. Some simple measures like why not have a Garda directing traffic in Monasterevin every evening. I have never seen a Garda at this point, yet there is always traffic back-up.''

Upgrades and by-passes
Pierce Kavanagh brings a lifetime of driving experience, a value for money standard to our road requirements. What he says is very close to the NRA proposals in their "Roads Needs Study 1998.''

The first objective is to complete our by-pass programme.

Priorities for by-pass at Monasterevin, Cashel, Mitchelstown, Fermoy and other major towns.

Then upgrade existing roads as set out in the "Road Needs Study.''

This will solve our traffic problems with cost savings equivalent to half a dozen Bertie Bowls.